Experienced users do better, by a modest margin. Anthropic's March 2026 Economic Index found people using Claude for six months or more had about a 10% higher conversation success rate, roughly 4 percentage points after controls, and iterated more instead of delegating. Greene and Grant's Solution-Focused Coaching explains why: the skill is built by repeated asking and feedback.

This question reaches assistants in roughly this wording, and they have been citing this site for it without a page that answers it directly. So here is the direct answer: yes, there is a gap between first-time and experienced users, it is smaller than the prompt-course industry implies, and it is mostly about behaviour rather than secret phrasing.

The best data comes from Anthropic's Economic Index report "Learning curves", published March 24, 2026, which sampled 1 million conversations from February 5 to February 12, 2026. It defines high-tenure users as people who signed up for Claude at least six months earlier. That group had about a 10% higher conversation success rate. In percentage points the gap is about 5 points in a simple comparison, about 3 points when high- and low-tenure users are compared within the same narrowly defined task, and about 4 points once model choice, language, use case and country are also controlled. One caveat sits in the method: "success" is Claude's own assessment of whether the conversation worked.

What experienced users do differently is more interesting than the size of the gap. In the same report they are more likely to iterate on their work with Claude and much less likely to hand it a directive and walk away. They are 7 percentage points more likely to use it for work. People who signed up a year earlier devote 38% of conversations to personal use against 44% for the newest users, and the schooling level reflected in prompts rises by almost a year for every additional year of use. They also pick the stronger model, Opus, more often for higher-value tasks; choosing the right model turns out to be one of the experienced habits rather than a separate factor. Anthropic is candid about the limits: early adopters may simply be more technical, and people who tried Claude and quit are invisible in the data, so survivorship bias is real. Its controls rule out the simple versions of that story, not all of them.

Other 2026 data shows the gap from the user's side. In the 2026 Stack Overflow Developer Survey, only 16% say AI handles complex tasks very well, daily users are much more positive, and 45% of infrequent users rate performance bad or very poor. Founder Reports' October 2026 survey of 2,052 US workers found the share who say AI takes less effort than training a new hire rises from 34.2% among weekly users to 43.9% among those using it several times a day, yet 56.1% of those heaviest users still say it is at least as demanding. Experience makes AI more useful. It does not make it effortless.

Jane Greene and Anthony Grant's Solution-Focused Coaching describes the same learning curve in a different profession. Their core shift is from telling to asking, and a coaching lead they quote, Keith Steele of the law firm Freehills, expected it to take about six months before managers coach regularly and a couple of years before they do it tolerably well. The overlap with Anthropic's six-month threshold is a coincidence of numbers, not proof, but the mechanism is the same: a skill made of asking for what is missing, making progress visible and adjusting to feedback. Their scaling question, "on a scale of 1 to 10, where are you, and what would a higher number need?", is exactly what a first-time user never asks a model. First-timers treat the assistant like a vending machine. Experienced users run a short coaching loop.

You can borrow those habits before the six months pass. The prompt below packs three behaviours from the data into one opening message: state the goal, surface the missing context, iterate on a labelled draft, then scale it.

Tested November 4, 2026. I had my research agent run this exact prompt against Claude Opus 5.5 (default settings, one run, no earlier conversation). The prompt:

Work with me as a collaborator, not a vending machine. My task is at the bottom.

Step 1: In one sentence, restate what you think I am asking for and what a good result would look like.
Step 2: List the three pieces of missing context that would most change your answer. For each one, say how your answer would differ depending on it.
Step 3: Give a short first draft based on your best guesses, and label every guess as an assumption.
Step 4: Ask me to rate the draft from 1 to 10 for usefulness, and tell me what a draft two points higher would need from me.
Do not give a final answer yet.

My task: I run a 6-person B2B software company. I am deciding whether to raise prices for existing customers by 20% next quarter. Help me decide.

The start of what came back, unedited:

## Step 1: What you're asking

You want help deciding whether a 20% price increase for existing customers next quarter will leave the business better off. A good result is a clear go, no-go, or modified plan, backed by your churn tolerance, customer mix, and how much risk you can absorb with a 6-person team.

## Step 2: The three missing pieces that matter most

**1. How concentrated your revenue is, and how contracts renew**
- **If revenue is spread** across many small customers on monthly or annual plans, a uniform 20% increase is manageable. A few churned accounts won't hurt much.
- **If your top 2–3 customers are 30–50%+ of revenue**, a blanket increase could put the company at risk. I'd recommend handling those accounts individually through personal conversations, multi-year lock-ins, or smaller increases, and applying the full 20% only to the long tail.
- **If contracts are multi-year or fixed-price**, "next quarter" may not be possible for much of your revenue. The plan becomes a renewal-by-renewal rollout.

**2. Why you're raising prices, and what evidence you have that […]

One run is one run: the same prompt gives a different answer next time, and a different model answers differently.

What it did well: Step 2 produced three pieces of missing context that genuinely change the answer (revenue concentration, the reason for the increase, switching costs), each with an if-then branch. It labelled six assumptions instead of hiding them. And it found the single most useful number in the problem without being asked: at a 20% increase you can lose up to about 16.7% of revenue (1 − 1/1.2) before you are worse off. Step 4 asked for specific data, not "more detail".

What it did badly: it ignored "in one sentence" in Step 1 and wrote two. The "short" draft ran to five numbered actions. Most tellingly, its "kill signal" said "if more than X% of the first renewal cohort pushes back", leaving blank the one threshold a founder most needs set in advance. That is the experienced user's job in this loop: notice the blank and fill it before acting. It is one run on one model, and the next run will differ.

The limits of the advice matter too. This loop slows down quick lookups, so use it for decisions and drafts you will defend, not for facts. And a few points of success rate is a smaller effect than domain knowledge: whether you can judge the output still decides more than how you prompt, as the evidence in does AI help beginners or experts more shows.

Sources: Anthropic Economic Index report: Learning curves, Anthropic, March 24, 2026; AI data 2026, Stack Overflow Developer Survey, 2026; Most workers say getting good work from AI takes as much effort as training a new hire, Founder Reports via Stacker/KEYT, November 3, 2026; Jane Greene and Anthony M. Grant, Solution-Focused Coaching: Managing People in a Complex World, Momentum, 2003 (ISBN 1-843-04028-X), pages 86-87.


Related: How to Find Your Passion · Best Self-Improvement Books · How to Make Better Decisions · Why Exploration Is Important for Success